The Smeg 2-Slice Retro Toaster (TSF01) isn’t just an appliance — it’s a piece of art disguised as kitchen equipment. With its unmistakable curves, glossy enamel finish, and Italian craftsmanship, it has become the definitive icon of the modern retro aesthetic. But behind its sculpted exterior lies a surprisingly capable machine that balances beauty with performance. This review takes a closer look at how the Smeg performs in design, usability, and reliability to see if it truly earns its premium reputation.
Design and Build Quality
Few kitchen products are as visually striking as a Smeg toaster. The TSF01’s rounded 1950s silhouette immediately draws attention, and its weight hints at quality before you even plug it in. The body is constructed from powder-coated steel with polished chrome accents, available in a wide range of color options — from soft pastels like cream and mint green to bold finishes like red, black, and royal blue.
Everything about its construction feels deliberate. The lever moves with a satisfying resistance, the dial clicks with mechanical precision, and the rubberized feet anchor it firmly to the counter. The toaster’s smooth enamel coating resists fingerprints and wipes clean effortlessly. Even the small chrome Smeg logo feels like a badge of craftsmanship rather than branding.
In a market filled with lightweight imitations, the TSF01 stands out as one of the few toasters that actually feels built to last. It’s as much a decorative centerpiece as it is a functional tool — the kind of product you leave proudly on display rather than hide in a cupboard.
Performance and Toasting Quality
A beautiful design means little without results, and fortunately, the Smeg performs impressively. With 950 watts of power, it produces consistent, evenly browned slices with remarkable precision. Each cycle feels calibrated — no patchy heating, no overdone edges. The internal heating elements distribute warmth evenly, meaning both sides of the bread receive the same level of browning.
The six browning levels cover the full range from light golden to deep brown, and the dial is finely tuned enough that even small adjustments make a visible difference. The slots are wide and deep, accommodating everything from standard white bread to artisan sourdough and bagels. In tests, the Smeg produced uniform results across all slice types, a mark of good element placement and heat stability.
It also recovers quickly between cycles, allowing multiple rounds without losing consistency — a rare strength in many stylish toasters that prioritise form over function.
Features and Ease of Use
The TSF01 manages to include modern features without breaking its minimalist design philosophy. The reheat, defrost, and bagel settings are built into the control panel with subtle chrome buttons that blend seamlessly into the front fascia. The reheat function warms toast without further browning, while the defrost mode gently brings frozen bread to temperature before toasting, preserving texture.
The bagel setting toasts one side more than the other, achieving a crisp interior and soft outer surface. It’s a thoughtful addition for those who enjoy bakery-style breakfasts.
One of the more understated conveniences is the high-lift mechanism, which raises smaller slices high enough to retrieve safely — no more burning fingertips. The removable stainless-steel crumb tray also slides out smoothly, keeping maintenance simple and preventing burnt residue over time.
Unlike some competitors, the Smeg remains stable and quiet during operation. The exterior stays cool, even after several consecutive cycles, making it safer in busy kitchens. It’s an appliance that feels effortless to use day after day.
Durability and Maintenance
Durability is where the Smeg distinguishes itself from most toasters in its price bracket. The thick steel body and enamel coating resist chipping and discoloration, even after years of daily use. The levers and dials are mechanical rather than purely electronic, which makes them less prone to failure.
Maintenance is minimal — a quick wipe after each use and regular emptying of the crumb tray are all that’s needed to keep it performing at its best. Smeg also provides a two-year manufacturer’s warranty, reflecting confidence in its engineering. In practice, most users report years of consistent performance without degradation, provided the toaster isn’t misused or overloaded.
Value and Pricing
Retailing typically between £130 and £160, the Smeg 2-Slice Retro Toaster sits firmly in the premium category. It’s undeniably expensive compared to functional equivalents, but this isn’t a product purchased solely for utility. You’re paying for a combination of craftsmanship, durability, and design integrity.
Cheaper models can make toast; the Smeg makes a statement. It’s designed for buyers who appreciate quality materials, attention to detail, and the way an appliance can influence the atmosphere of a kitchen. For those people, the price feels justified — an investment in both function and form.
While the performance is excellent, the value comes from its longevity and the way it enhances the kitchen environment. It doesn’t just toast bread; it changes how your mornings feel.
Verdict
The Smeg 2-Slice Retro Toaster (TSF01) is more than a nostalgic appliance — it’s a small luxury that turns a simple morning ritual into something elegant. It toasts evenly, cleans easily, and looks flawless from every angle. More importantly, it’s built like a proper machine, not a disposable gadget.
For design enthusiasts, homeowners who take pride in their kitchens, or anyone who believes that good form should always accompany function, the Smeg is the clear benchmark. It’s not the cheapest toaster you can buy — but it might be the last one you’ll ever need.